Daniel Minahan, MSPM, PMP, CM, CAPM, CSM
Picture
Project Manager, Project Leader, what’s the difference? Well, if done correctly there can be a great difference with one goal in mind, project execution.

Leadership and leader are thrown around in a way that sometimes can allude to those leading or managing projects, missions, etc., but are we talking about management or leadership?

Management is defined as the process of dealing with or controlling things or people.

Leadership is defined as the person who leads or commands a group, organization, or country.

Very similar, but truly different roles in a business setting. Leader is thrown around all too often as someone in charge, but shouldn’t we leave that title to someone who can actually lead? In the management definition, it doesn’t say they “lead”, but deal or control. Everyone knows some managers that deal or control, but can’t lead. For the leader it does not say they are good at dealing or controlling, but rather leading or commanding. How many leaders have we known that were not good at paperwork, not very organized, or could not draft a technical document, but they could lead people all day to accomplish anything? Very different. The military has seen both before in the role of Officer and Noncommissioned Officer (NCO). There are plenty of great Officers that were managers and leaders and NCOs that were managers and leaders; however, in the context of project management, they both have roles to fill. The military does project management all the time in most aspects of daily operations. Deployments are a project, exercises in the field are projects, and even going to the range is a project. If we follow the five phases of project management from the Project Management Body of Knowledge, here’s an example of a qualification range (not all inclusive as a range is a lot more than below):

Initiating – Company or Battalion Commander determines the need for a qualification range to get the troops qualified. An officer in charge (OIC) and noncommissioned officer in charge (NCOIC) are selected to run the range.

Planning – The OIC and NCOIC plan the entire range from ammo pickup, to troop movement to the range, to firing, and then closing the range. Every last detail is planned to ensure success.

Executing – The day starts with vehicles being lined up outside the arms room and weapons draw. The NCOIC is running around executing the entire plan from the beginning of the morning, through the range, and to the last firing order.

Monitoring and Controlling – The NCOIC is ensuring his team leads are executing their duties and all the deliverables are being delivered (e.g., weapons draw, vehicles lined up, troops arriving, range being set up for firing, firing orders qualifying, and paperwork being collected on the troops qualifying).

Closing – Final deliverables of all firers qualified, range cleanup, weapon turn in, and after action review are all delivered. The NCOIC releases the troops and team leads and ensures the OIC is good to go with all the paperwork necessary for the commander.

Replace the OIC with project manager and NCOIC with project leader. The OIC is responsible for the entire project and will do the majority of the planning, whereas the NCOIC will do the majority of the execution (in a perfect environment). The OIC is present the entire time, but it is the NCOIC who usually has more experience and knowledge of the mission or project to lead the troops. Usually a Lieutenant is given the responsibilty of being the OIC and a senior Staff Sergeant or Sergeant First Class (U.S. Army) will be the NCOIC. The Lieutenant, as the OIC or project manager, is trained to be a manager and the NCOIC has been groomed to be a leader. Both are necessary to accomplish the mission and the same is true in project management.

Watching Band of Brothers last night, episode “The Breaking Point”, I saw what I was explaining above in action. This episode was about the final days in Bastogne before they launched the attack on the town of Foy. The theme was about the lack of leadership in their company commander (manager) and the company First Sergeant, played by Donnie Wahlberg, portraying the true leader he was. We also saw both a great manager and leader in action, CPT Speirs, who at the time was maybe beyond what is acceptable in today’s military, but followed by many and retired as a Lieutenant Colonel in the Army.

In the simplest form, a great leader has people willing to follow, while a manager may have those willing, but also unwilling to follow, but are required to due to the position they hold.

A great project manager doesn’t need to be the expert on the project, but rather a solid manager that deals and controls people. The project leader should be your expert and should leave the managerial aspects to the project manager. In a perfect world the project manager will be both manager and leader, but reality sets in and it is not always the case, so why not have both?

There are many names for the leader on the project, from subject matter expert to project engineer to name a few, but why not establish the establish the position.

Are you a better project manager or project leader?


 


Comments

Annon
09/30/2016 12:25pm

Hmmm......looks pretty self explanatory to me, do you really need a certification to figure this out?

Reply
Daniel Minahan
10/01/2016 7:29pm

Certifications are a great way to show your level of knowledge and will prove your dedication to a craft. Employers are starting to require PMP, for instance, as a qualification for hire. If you want to know more, email me at dan@minutemencg.com and I will go more in-depth. Thanks!

Reply

Managing and leading are sometimes used interchangeably, but it really has different meanings. The task of a manager is to plan, organize, and control. On the other hand, the leader's task is not just to lead, but to inspire and influence people as well. I just know the difference between the two in the business world and team work. Anyway, in this context, I learned about the difference between a Project Manager and a Project Leader in a military way.

I think the reason why they assume that PMP's are project managers is because PMI's PMP certification is the most important industry-recognized certification for project managers. So, people just assume that just because you have a certain certification, you already achieved the position where it's important.

Reply
Jonathan Brown, PMP
10/20/2016 8:11am

Great example of project management in the military. Thousands of departing military service members need help understanding how to translate their military experience to the civilian world, and you do a great job of supporting that very important effort.

Reply
05/16/2017 8:51am

Nuvega Lash to a inexperienced- power device which it could be barely better Nuvega Lash you're the usage of electricity from renewable sources. electrical Nuvega Lash products are very electricity green. you do now not need to Nuvega Lash save fuel which include propane.in case Nuvega Lash you are using an electric powered.

http://guidemesupplements.com/nuvega-lash/

Reply

Leadership & management are likely same words but the meaning of both of them is quite different. Leadership is like to lead the whole of nation & managing all the problems and resolving them, while management is to control some limited people.

Reply
04/27/2017 6:02am

Thank you for posting this post and I work in http://www.militaryvehiclemodels.com as a Engineer,
Authority and Responsibility are not periodic proposed arm in arm yet they are inter-dependent and both crave to be considered when defining the undertaking managers role. Assigning long row to hoe for a function without a xerox degree of restraint is as unsound as delegating power without function yet easily too regular we handle long row to hoe managers saddled by all of the function of a project without conscience to their authority.

Reply
05/08/2017 12:28am

My mate and i read phrase for expression, here you give a fascinating article could be a materials reference point me in the work, much thanks.

Reply
05/17/2017 8:59am

Endurance Test X consequently it would be clever for you to shop for underground Endurance Test X playing cards in suitable prices and thoroughly use it like of top notch value.Endurance Test X economic investments are indeed a need to for a person future. Endurance Test X these financial investments Endurance Test X need to be nourished for the man.

http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/endurance-test-x/

Reply
05/18/2017 7:17am

Bio Rocket Blast has the criminal proper thus far whomever they want to without Bio Rocket Blast judgment and it's your right to live your existence in a manner that Bio Rocket Blast makes you content material without being involved Bio Rocket Blast approximately what others recommend. Bio Rocket Blast following positive suggestions and laws.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/bio-rocket-blast/

Reply
05/19/2017 7:07am

NO2 Core creatine need to now not be used continuously and also you need to NO2 Core drink lots of water while the use of both creatine and protein NO2 Core supplements to keep away from destructive side consequences.NO2 Core in case you are looking to construct a bigger extra NO2 Core muscular frame.

http://guidemesupplements.com/no2-core/

Reply
05/22/2017 6:03am

Epic Male Enhancement who're in love those with the others. romance does Epic Male Enhancement now not mean $exuality. we speak approximately the male love. Epic Male Enhancement as an example whilst homo$exual single Epic Male Enhancement which loves every other man it's miles within the love or the romance. Epic Male Enhancement the single guys seeking.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/epic-male-enhancement/

Reply
05/23/2017 6:10am

Bio Rocket Blast blood ranges of this hormone becomes noticeable as early as seven Bio Rocket Blast days after ovulation. the level will rise evenly attaining a peak at about Bio Rocket Blast to a few months into gestation. after this factor the hormone level will drop progressively until Bio Rocket Blast the factor of beginning.

http://guidemesupplements.com/bio-rocket-blast/

Reply
05/24/2017 7:19am

Bio Rocket Blast the leap forward components of pro villus changed into designed Bio Rocket Blast to block dht and deliver the right vitamins for your body specially Bio Rocket Blast tailored to save you hair loss and that will help you regrow hair naturally. Bio Rocket Blast sturdy wholesome hair begins with Bio Rocket Blast the right dietary constructing blocks.

http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/bio-rocket-blast/

Reply
05/26/2017 6:43am

Right Pick Muscle is a multi factorial method that could involve reduced hormone Right Pick Muscle tiers mainly and testosterone a lack of adequate protein and Right Pick Muscle calories in the weight loss plan oxidation strain inflammatory Right Pick Muscle strategies chronic low stage Right Pick Muscle weight loss plan caused metabolic acidosis in addition.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/right-pick-muscle/

Reply
05/27/2017 6:53am

Power Boost XI additionally containing omega-3 fatty acids and nutrition d.Power Boost XI carbohydrates are the gas of the muscle mass. it burns brief Power Boost XI whilst you are working out. your body will paintings off these Power Boost XI until it runs out making it hotel to body fats.Power Boost XI if you pick out to consume.

http://guidemesupplements.com/power-boost-xi/

Reply
05/29/2017 3:47am

Easily, the article is actually the best topic on this registry related issue. I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantasti c lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates.

Reply
05/29/2017 3:50am

Bio Rocket Blast do male enhancement products absolutely paintings the Bio Rocket Blast answer is sure however simplest if the men devote themselves to a Bio Rocket Blast best penile expansion tablet and complement it with industry Bio Rocket Blast permitted sporting activities stretches Bio Rocket Blast and a healthful way of life.

http://jackedmuscleextremeadvice.com/bio-rocket-blast/

Reply
05/30/2017 5:44am

Enduro Force the notable element about ripfast merchandise that is really worth Enduro Force being taken under consideration is that they without a doubt work. Enduro Force and the witnesses that assist this fact are the unswerving customers Enduro Force all over the world worried with their suitable Enduro Force look and wonderful performances.

http://t-rexmuscleadvice.com/enduro-force/

Reply
05/31/2017 6:17am

Bio Rocket Blast which additionally known as impotence is an inevitability Bio Rocket Blast that incorporates developing age however the fact is that Bio Rocket Blast erectile dysfunction can arise in any age. but the precise issue Bio Rocket Blast is that market has a big wide variety of medicinal Bio Rocket Blast drugs to deal with erectile dysfunction wish.

http://glycematefacts.com/bio-rocket-blast/

Reply
06/01/2017 5:22am

Elevate IGF it is advised that you consume per-workout food and dietary Elevate IGF supplements about one and a hours before your exercising so that the Elevate IGF meals has time to digest.muscle constructing food should additionally Elevate IGF be ate up after a workout preferably Elevate IGF inside twenty minutes.

http://www.healthsupreviews.com/elevate-igf/

Reply
06/03/2017 3:11am

Elevate IGF all assert that they've the healthiest way of assisting you to burn fat Elevate IGF construct muscle and get into the shape of your existence.Elevate IGF this results in a number of water cooler communicate Elevate IGF but it is not excellent for you dwelling a healthy life.

http://jackedmuscleextremeadvice.com/elevate-igf/

Reply
07/27/2017 9:30am

Reply



Leave a Reply